This week we will dig deeper into Shabanu.
- Please answer the questions below in your Google Drive.
- Call the document "Blog 10, Analyzing Shabanu".
- Answer each as a quote sandwich. In other words, start with your ideas about the question, then give a quote to prove it, then finish with your ideas.
- What do Dadi and Shabanu encounter when they attempt to bury Grandfather? What appears to be lacking in the personalities of Sulaiman and the villagers in general?
- What do Shabanu and Phulan find while they are out hunting for sito? What do Dadi’s actions suggest about his character and beliefs?
- A dilemma is any situation requiring a choice between equal—often equally unpleasant—alternatives. Explain Shabanu’s dilemma when she and Phulan meet Nazir Mohammad and his hunters. Shabanu’s choosing to save her sister from rape leads to the story’s climax. On p.154, why is Shabanu angry at her sister?
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDelete
Delete1.What do Dadi and Shabanu encounter when they attempt to bury Grandfather? What appears to be lacking in the personalities of Sulaiman and the villagers in general?
- Dadi found shelter among the herd and is barely alive. The family rushes him inside. He softly insists on traveling to Derawar, where he will be buried as a soldier.
2.What do Shabanu and Phulan find while they are out hunting for sito?
- Phulan and Shabanu wander off in search of a sito, a desert plant with succulent, watery roots. At the top of a dune, they catch site of a turban tied to the top of a tall shrub. Phulan is frightened: travelers who are lost or thirsty tie their turbans to the tops of trees in hopes that someone will see the turban and bring water.
3.What do Dadi’s actions suggest about his character and beliefs?
A dilemma is any situation requiring a choice between equal—often equally unpleasant—alternatives. Explain Shabanu’s dilemma when she and Phulan meet Nazir Mohammad and his hunters. Shabanu’s choosing to save her sister from rape leads to the story’s climax. On p.154, why is Shabanu angry at her sister?
- That women should be protected and not used as tools for personal satisfaction , there are many people that just want to make money for fun while they’re actually damaging something else or someone in one way or the other.
- Shabanu thinks about what a bad situation on which we just got in , now how would we get out from those hunters . “ Oh , I could kill her. What is she thinking?” on page 154.
- Shabanu is angry at Phulan because she could be taken by Nazir Mohammad for his whole idea about making money by giving womens to men who use them .
Mohammed Rahman
ReplyDelete1) What do Dadi and Shabanu encounter when they attempt to bury Grandfather? What appears to be lacking in the personalities of Sulaiman and the villagers in general?
=> Dadi and shabanu had problem when they tried to bury grandfather at derawar. They tried to to bury him where grandfather wanted them to but the keeper of the tombs didn’t let dadi to bury grandfather because only nawabs wife is buried there and no one had buried anyone for the last 20 years. Grandfather gave his life for the nawabs land but they denied him.
=> “The nawab doesn’t even have an army now, except for the bodyguard that protects his family from his enemies...” (pg 134)
=> This shows that Dadi and shabanu tried to bury grandfathers dead body but they faced some consequences. Grandfather almost gave his life for the nawabs army but the tomb keeper denied dadi to bury grandfather.
2) What do Shabanu and Phulan find while they are out hunting for sito? What do Dadi’s actions suggest about his character and beliefs?
=> Shabanu and phulan finds nazir mohammad and his man hunting birds. They tried to take phulan but shabanu and phulan came back to the camp and told dadi and dadi got mad as if he’s going to kill nazir and his mens.
=> “ Dadi’s eyes are harden...No says mama,fear shaking in her voice. she stands and dadi comes out, the old country gun glinting gray and ugly in his hands “Abassi” she says, her eyes begging” (pg 158)
=> This shows Dadi got mad when he heard nazir mohammad coming phulan he took his gun and tried to go and face them but he stops when mama urge him. Dadi loves shabanu and phulan he can’t let anything happen to them when he’s alive.
3) A dilemma is any situation requiring a choice between equal—often equally unpleasant—alternatives. Explain Shabanu’s dilemma when she and Phulan meet Nazir Mohammad and his hunters. Shabanu’s choosing to save her sister from rape leads to the story’s climax. On p.154, why is Shabanu angry at her sister?
=> When Shabanu and met nazir mohammad and his hunters phulan wasn’t there but
when she came back and saw nazir mohammad and his man she looked defiantly . Shabanu had choices but she loves her sister that she can’t run without phulan so she waited for phulan and then they both run away with xush dil and mithoo. Shabanu got angry at her sister because phulan is acting with nazir mohammad and his mans as she’s not a girl but a boy.
=> “we are both trapped. Both of us have jars of water on our heads. we can’t turn and ran away from this leering fat man. The of him sweating over phulan makes me ill” (page 155)
=> This shows that shabanu had choices that either she could ran alone without taking phulan with her or she could stand there like a brave women and take her sister with her and ran away together. She didn’t want to give phulan on nazir mohammad’s hand because phulan is getting married soon and she will have a good future.
Mohammed sujon
ReplyDeleteCorrection :Q.3 first answer Should be, When shabanu and PHULAN met nazir mohammad and his hunters phulan wasn’t there but
when she came back and saw nazir mohammad and his man she looked defiantly . Shabanu had choices but she loves her sister that she can’t run without phulan so she waited for phulan and then they both run away with xush dil and mithoo. Shabanu got angry at her sister because phulan is acting with nazir mohammad and his mans as she’s not a girl but a boy.
1) What do Dadi and Shabanu encounter when they attempt to bury Grandfather? What appears to be lacking in the personalities of Sulaiman and the villagers in general?
ReplyDelete=> Dadi and shabanu had problem when they tried to bury grandfather at derawar. They tried to to bury him where grandfather wanted them to but the keeper of the tombs didn’t let dadi to bury grandfather because only nawabs wife is buried there and no one had buried anyone for the last 20 years. Grandfather gave his life for the nawabs land but they denied him.
=> “The nawab doesn’t even have an army now, except for the bodyguard that protects his family from his enemies...” (pg 134)
=> This shows that Dadi and shabanu tried to bury grandfathers dead body but they faced some consequences. Grandfather almost gave his life for the nawabs army but the tomb keeper denied dadi to bury grandfather.
2) What do Shabanu and Phulan find while they are out hunting for sito? What do Dadi’s actions suggest about his character and beliefs?
=> Shabanu and phulan finds nazir mohammad and his man hunting birds. They tried to take phulan but shabanu and phulan came back to the camp and told dadi and dadi got mad as if he’s going to kill nazir and his mens.
=> “ Dadi’s eyes are harden...No says mama,fear shaking in her voice. she stands and dadi comes out, the old country gun glinting gray and ugly in his hands “Abassi” she says, her eyes begging” (pg 158)
=> This shows Dadi got mad when he heard nazir mohammad coming phulan he took his gun and tried to go and face them but he stops when mama urge him. Dadi loves shabanu and phulan he can’t let anything happen to them when he’s alive.
3) A dilemma is any situation requiring a choice between equal—often equally unpleasant—alternatives. Explain Shabanu’s dilemma when she and Phulan meet Nazir Mohammad and his hunters. Shabanu’s choosing to save her sister from rape leads to the story’s climax. On p.154, why is Shabanu angry at her sister?
=> When Shabanu and met nazir mohammad and his hunters phulan wasn’t there but
when she came back and saw nazir mohammad and his man she looked defiantly . Shabanu had choices but she loves her sister that she can’t run without phulan so she waited for phulan and then they both run away with xush dil and mithoo. Shabanu got angry at her sister because phulan is acting with nazir mohammad and his mans as she’s not a girl but a boy.
=> “we are both trapped. Both of us have jars of water on our heads. we can’t turn and ran away from this leering fat man. The of him sweating over phulan makes me ill” (page 155)
=> This shows that shabanu had choices that either she could ran alone without taking phulan with her or she could stand there like a brave women and take her sister with her and ran away together. She didn’t want to give phulan on nazir mohammad’s hand because phulan is getting married soon and she will have a good future.
ReplyDeleteChen, Lin
What do Dadi and Shabanu encounter when they attempt to bury Grandfather? What appears to be lacking in the personalities of Sulaiman and the villagers in general?
Dadi washes his thin and wasted body with the water, chanting prayers for the head. And Shabanu bandaged that toe for him and search for a burial place. Sulaiman does not speak that is shows that not respectful and the villagers are unfriendly and poor wells. Hamir’s family is not expecting them for another month and they decide stay in Derawar.
What do Shabanu and Phulan find while they are out hunting for sito? What do Dadi’s actions suggest about his character and beliefs?
They dray water at the well, Xhush Dil pulls off Puhlan;s chadr and waves it, and she feels happiness.Dadi was worry about the land. If the land is fertile, Nazir Mohammad requires that get it. If it is not, he does not want it. He tries to give the crops as the money in payment. He want it that is going to become the rich and he can get many money.
A dilemma is any situation requiring a choice between equal—often equally unpleasant—alternatives. Explain Shabanu’s dilemma when she and Phulan meet Nazir Mohammad and his hunters. Shabanu’s choosing to save her sister from rape leads to the story’s climax. On p.154, why is Shabanu angry at her sister?
Shabnu understands that they are not good people, they treat the woman like the slave and she knows that they see Phulan, they will want her. The Dadi and Hamir won’t bear for this thing, she’s certain. Shabanu angry at her sister because of her beautiful figure and nice face. He wants her sister, then he gives her cash and sends her back to her family after he is finished with her, she was sacrifice.
qianhong huang
ReplyDelete1.
What do Dadi and Shabanu encounter when they attempt to bury Grandfather? What appears to be lacking in the personalities of Sulaiman and the villagers in general?
when Dadi and Shabanu encounter to bury Grandfather , Sulaiman told them that they can not to bury her grandfather in this place, there are many years no people can bury in there. we can see that Sulaiman is Cruel because he does not let grandfather to bury in this land and the villagers not friendly because only Shahzada help them.quotes from page 133 “Nobody has been buried here in twenty years.”and page 135 “but the village is unfriendly,and Shahzada is the only helpful woul we’ve found here.”
2.
What do Shabanu and Phulan find while they are out hunting for sito? What do Dadi’s actions suggest about his character and beliefs?
Shabanu and Phulan find Nazir Mohammad and his laughters are hunting the birds,and they saw Phulan ,also wants to take her away,later they go back and tell to their dadi. Quote on page 157 “‘they say they’ll pay.they want her.they saw Mithoo coming here,and the fire was burning.’”
when dadi heard that ,he take out the gun and angry ,he knows that they have problems coming soon.he does not wants his daughters been in dangerous. Quote on page 157 “she stands and dadi comes out ,the old country hun glinting gray and ugly in his hands.”
3.
A dilemma is any situation requiring a choice between equal—often equally unpleasant—alternatives. Explain Shabanu’s dilemma when she and Phulan meet Nazir Mohammad and his hunters. Shabanu’s choosing to save her sister from rape leads to the story’s climax. On p.154, why is Shabanu angry at her sister?
When they met Nazir Mohammad ,first Shabanu afraid that they will hurt Phulan but she can not go and left Phulan alone,but when Phulan see them ,she does not feel alarmed and still standing and looking .Quote on page 154 “Phulan put her hand on her hip and thrusts it forward....under her thin cotton tunic.”
Jing Jiang
ReplyDelete1.What do Dadi and Shabanu encounter when they attempt to bury Grandfather? What appears to be lacking in the personalities of Sulaiman and the villagers in general?
When Dadi and Shabanu attempt to bury Grandfather, Sulaiman told them they cannot bury grandfather in there. Sulaiman isn’t friendly and the villagers also have lacking the same personality. In quote on page 134, “The nawab doesn’t even have an army now, except for the bodyguard that protects his family from his enemies...” This quote tells us Dadi and Shabanu tried to bury grandfather but Silaiman refuse them, he didn’t let them bury grandfather in Derawar.
2.What do Shabanu and Phulan find while they are out hunting for sito? What do Dadi’s actions suggest about his character and beliefs?
Shabanu and Phulan find Nazir Mohammad and the bird he hunted. Dadi is angry but he also take care with his family, in the quote on page 158, “Shabanu, you and Phulan help Auntie pack the most important things. Leave what isn’t important. Take the dowry, bedding, and food. But keep the fire going.” THis quote tells us Dadi is take care for his family, he prepares everything done for his family, and then left himself.
3.A dilemma is any situation requiring a choice between equal—often equally unpleasant—alternatives. Explain Shabanu’s dilemma when she and Phulan meet Nazir Mohammad and his hunters. Shabanu’s choosing to save her sister from rape leads to the story’s climax. On p.154, why is Shabanu angry at her sister.
Shabanu and Phulan trapped by Nazir Mohammad and his hunters, she can not run by herself, but Phulan is not so agile, if they run together, they may get caught by Nazir Mohammad again. Shabanu is angry at her sister because they get caught by Nazir Mohammad, but Phulan didn’t notice they are dangerous, so Shabanu feel angry about that.
jianzhou li
ReplyDeleteWhat do Dadi and Shabanu encounter when they attempt to bury Grandfather? What appears to be lacking in the personalities of Sulaiman and the villagers in general?
Dadi and Shabanu encounter to bury Grandfather , Sulaiman told them that they can not to bury her grandfather in this place, there are many years no people can bury in there. quotes from page133 “Nobody has been buried here in twenty years.”and page 135 “but the village is unfriendly,and Shahzada is the only helpful woul we’ve found here.”we can see that Sulaiman is Cruel because he does not let grandfather to bury in this land and the villagers not friendly because only Shahzada help them.
1.
What do Shabanu and Phulan find while they are out hunting for sito? What do Dadi’s actions suggest about his character and beliefs?
Shabanu and Phulan find Nazir Mohammad and the bird he hunted. Dadi is angry but he also take care with his family,The quote on page 158, “Shabanu, you and Phulan help Auntie pack the most important things. Leave what isn’t important. Take the dowry, bedding, and food. But keep the fire going.” THis quote show us Dadi is take care for his family, he prepares everything done for his family, and then left himself.
2.
A dilemma is any situation requiring a choice between equal—often equally unpleasant—alternatives. Explain Shabanu’s dilemma when she and Phulan meet Nazir Mohammad and his hunters. Shabanu’s choosing to save her sister from rape leads to the story’s climax. On p.154, why is Shabanu angry at her sister?
When they met Nazir Mohammad ,first Shabanu afraid that they will hurt Phulan but she can not go and left Phulan alone,but when Phulan see them ,she does not feel alarmed and still standing and looking .Quote on page 154 “Phulan put her hand on her hip and thrusts it forward....under her thin cotton tunic.”
Michelle Alvarado
ReplyDeleteWhat do Dadi and Shabanu encounter when they attempt to bury Grandfather? What appears to be lacking in the personalities of Sulaiman and the villagers in general?
=> Dadi and shabanu had problem when they tried to bury grandfather at derawar. They tried to to bury him where grandfather wanted them to but the keeper of the tombs didn’t let dadi to bury grandfather because only nawabs wife is buried there and no one had buried anyone for the last 20 years. Grandfather gave his life for the nawabs land but they denied him.
=> “The nawab doesn’t even have an army now, except for the bodyguard that protects his family from his enemies...” (pg 134)
=> This shows that Dadi and shabanu tried to bury grandfathers dead body but they faced some consequences. Grandfather almost gave his life for the nawabs army but the tomb keeper denied dadi to bury grandfather.
What do Shabanu and Phulan find while they are out hunting for sito? What do Dadi’s actions suggest about his character and beliefs?
=> Shabanu and phulan finds nazir mohammad and his man hunting birds.
=> “ Dadi’s eyes are harden...No says mama,fear shaking in her voice. she stands and dadi comes out, the old country gun glinting gray and ugly in his hands “Abassi” she says, her eyes begging” (pg 158).
=> This shows Dadi got mad when he heard nazir mohammad coming phulan he took his gun and tried to go and face them.
Dadi loves shabanu and phulan he can’t let anything happen to them when he’s alive.
A dilemma is any situation requiring a choice between equal—often equally unpleasant—alternatives. Explain Shabanu’s dilemma when she and Phulan meet Nazir Mohammad and his hunters. Shabanu’s choosing to save her sister from rape leads to the story’s climax. On p.154, why is Shabanu angry at her sister?
mohammad and his hunters phulan wasn’t there, but when she came back and saw nazir mohammad and his man she looked defiantly . Shabanu had choices but she loves her sister that she can’t run without phulan so she waited for phulan and then they both run away with xush dil and mithoo.
Shabanu got angry at her sister because phulan is acting with nazir mohammad and his mans as she’s not a girl but a boy.
What do Dadi and Shabanu encounter when they attempt to bury Grandfather? What appears to be lacking in the personalities of Sulaiman and the villagers in general?
ReplyDeleteDadi and Shabanu encounter to bury Grandfather , Sulaiman told them that they can’t bury her grandfather in this place, In the past many years no people can bury in there. quotes from page133 “Nobody has been buried here in twenty years.”and page 135 “but the village is unfriendly,and Shahzada is the only helpful woul we’ve found here.”we can see that Sulaiman is Cruel because he doesn’t let grandfather body bury in this land and the villagers aren’t friendly because only Shahzada help them.
What do Shabanu and Phulan find while they are out hunting for sito? What do Dadi’s actions suggest about his character and beliefs?
Shabanu and phulan met Nazir Mohammad and his men are hunting birds. They tried to kidnap Phulan ,but Shabanu and Phulan came back to the camp and told dadi the story. Dadi got mad and fury about the action of Nazir Mohamamad.
In the qoute “ Dadi’s eyes are harden...No says mama,fear shaking in her voice. she stands and dadi comes out, the old country gun glinting gray and ugly in his hands “Abassi” she says, her eyes begging” (pg 158)
This shows that Dadi got mad when he heard nazir mohammad tried to take phulan and so he took his gun and tried to revenge them. Dadi loves shabanu and phulan so he felt angry when someone offend them.
A dilemma is any situation requiring a choice between equal—often equally unpleasant—alternatives. Explain Shabanu’s dilemma when she and Phulan meet Nazir Mohammad and his hunters. Shabanu’s choosing to save her sister from rape leads to the story’s climax. On p.154, why is Shabanu angry at her sister?
When Shabanu met nazir mohammad and his hunters ,phulan wasn’t helping
.Shabanu to argument. But shabanu loves her sister and that why she is protecting phulan so she waited for phulan and then they both run away with xush dil and mithoo. Shabanu got angry at her sister because phulan is acting with nazir mohammad and his men as she doesn’t give respect to herself and doesn’t stand up for herself.
In this quote “we are both trapped. Both of us have jars of water on our heads. we can’t turn and ran away from this leering fat man. The thought of him sweating over phulan makes me ill” (page 155)
This shows that shabanu tried to get away with a plan but Phulan was scared . Shabanu had to do everything by herself.
What do Dadi and Shabanu encounter when they attempt to bury Grandfather? What appears to be lacking in the personalities of Sulaiman and the villagers in general?
ReplyDeleteDadi and shabanu had problem when they tried to bury grandfather at derawar. They tried to to bury him where grandfather wanted them to but the keeper of the tombs didn’t let dadi to bury grandfather because only nawabs wife is buried there and no one had buried anyone for the last 20 years. Grandfather gave his life for the nawabs land but they denied him. “The nawab doesn’t even have an army now, except for the bodyguard that protects his family from his enemies...” (pg 134)
What do Shabanu and Phulan find while they are out hunting for sito? What do Dadi’s actions suggest about his character and beliefs?
shabanu and phulan find nazir mohmmad and the bird he hunted. dadi is angry but he also take care with his family, in quote on page 158. “ shabanu, you and phulan help auntie pack the most improtant things. leave what isn’t improtant. take the dowry, bedding, and food .”
this quote shows us that dadi was very care about his family, so he prepare everthing for his family.
A dilemma is any situation requiring a choice between equal—often equally unpleasant—alternatives. Explain Shabanu’s dilemma when she and Phulan meet Nazir Mohammad and his hunters. Shabanu’s choosing to save her sister from rape leads to the story’s climax. On p.154, why is Shabanu angry at her sister.
this page shows us that shabanu had choies that either she could ran alone withoout taking phulan with her or she could stand ther like a brave women and take her sister and run away together. on page 155 “ we are trapped. both of us have jars of water on your heads. we can’t turn and run away from this leering fat man “she didn’t wants to give phulan on nazir mohammad’s hand because phulan is getting married soon and she wiil have a good future.
What do Dadi and Shabanu encounter when they attempt to bury Grandfather? What appears to be lacking in the personalities of Sulaiman and the villagers in general?
ReplyDeleteAns- 1) What do Dadi and Shabanu encounter when they attempt to bury Grandfather? What appears to be lacking in the personalities of Sulaiman and the villagers in general?
Dadi and shabanu had problem when they tried to bury grandfather at derawar. They tried to to bury him where grandfather wanted them to but the keeper of the tombs didn’t let dadi to bury grandfather because only nawabs wife is buried there and no one had buried anyone for the last 20 years. Grandfather gave his life for the nawabs land but they denied him.
“The nawab doesn’t even have an army now, except for the bodyguard that protects his family from his enemies...” (pg 134)
This shows that Dadi and shabanu tried to bury grandfathers dead body but they faced some consequences. Grandfather almost gave his life for the nawabs army but the tomb keeper denied dadi to bury grandfather..
What do Shabanu and Phulan find while they are out hunting for sito? What do Dadi’s actions suggest about his character and beliefs?
Ans- Shabanu and phulan finds nazir mohammad and his man hunting birds. They tried to take phulan but shabanu and phulan came back to the camp and told dadi and dadi got mad as if he’s going to kill nazir and his mens.
“ Dadi’s eyes are harden...No says mama,fear shaking in her voice. she stands and dadi comes out, the old country gun glinting gray and ugly in his hands “Abassi” she says, her eyes begging” (pg 158)
This shows Dadi got mad when he heard nazir mohammad coming phulan he took his gun and tried to go and face them but he stops when mama urge him. Dadi loves shabanu and phulan he can’t let anything happen to them when he’s alive.
A dilemma is any situation requiring a choice between equally—often equally unpleasant—alternatives. Explain Shabanu’s dilemma when she and Phulan meet Nazir Mohammad and his hunters. Shabanu’s choosing to save her sister from rape leads to the story’s climax. On p.154, why is Shabanu angry at her sister?
When Shabanu and met nazir mohammad and his hunters phulan wasn’t there but
when she came back and saw nazir mohammad and his man she looked defiantly . Shabanu had choices but she loves her sister that she can’t run without phulan so she waited for phulan and then they both run away with xush dil and mithoo. Shabanu got angry at her sister because phulan is acting with nazir mohammad and his men as she’s not a girl but a boy.
“we are both trapped. Both of us have jars of water on our heads. we can’t turn and ran away from this leering fat man. The of him sweating over phulan makes me ill” (page 155)
This shows that shabanu had choices that either she could ran alone without taking phulan with her or she could stand there like a brave women and take her sister with her and ran away together. She didn’t want to give phulan on nazir mohammad’s hand because phulan is getting married soon and she will have a good future.
What do Dadi and Shabanu encounter when they attempt to bury Grandfather? What appears to be lacking in the personalities of Sulaiman and the villagers in general?
ReplyDeletethey have to find a place to bury grandfather. he is not able to bury in nawab`s graveyard.
in page 139 it says “ i konw it was impossible to bury him in the nawab`s graveyard ”
we could see from this quote ,they are all nice. they try their best to complete the promise from granfather.
What do Shabanu and Phulan find while they are out hunting for sito? What do Dadi’s actions suggest about his character and beliefs?
when shabanu and phulan are looking for sito, they discover a young man need help and need water , he is already die.
in page 124 it says “a traveler has tied his turban to the highest branch and should be waiting in the shade for someone to find hime and bring water. but no body is under the bush.”
dadi reaches into the jar and sprinkles a handful of water over the head of the grave in the hope that it will quench the man`s thirsty spirit.
A dilemma is any situation requiring a choice between equal—often equally unpleasant—alternatives. Explain Shabanu’s dilemma when she and Phulan meet Nazir Mohammad and his hunters. Shabanu’s choosing to save her sister from rape leads to the story’s climax. On p.154, why is Shabanu angry at her sister?
when phulan heard nazir monhammad say jewelry money and so on. she was attracted . she did a action that shabanu hate.
in page 154 it says “phulan puts her hand on her hip and thrusts it forward,a defiant look on her face . her breasts are high and firm under her thin cotton tunic.”
this quote can show us phulan did a wrong choice . shabanu was very angry mama has warned them before. she is extremely angry.
Abhi Patel
ReplyDeleteThis week we will dig deeper into Shabanu.
· Please answer the questions below in your Google Drive.
· Call the document "Blog 10, Analyzing Shabanu".
· Answer each as a quote sandwich. In other words, start with your ideas about the question, then give a quote to prove it, then finish with your ideas.
1. What do Dadi and Shabanu encounter when they attempt to bury Grandfather? What appears to be lacking in the personalities of Sulaiman and the villagers in general?
When dadi and shabanu went to bury grandfather than sulaiman comes and said that you can not bury grandfather here as well. We can see this quote on page 134”the newab doesn't even have an army now , except for the bodyguard that protest his family from enemies...” his voice is lost as we leave him behind with importance”
this quote tell us that sulaiman dosent want to bury grandfather and his reaction was bad and kind of angry as well.
2. What do Shabanu and Phulan find while they are out hunting for sito? What do Dadi’s actions suggest about his character and beliefs?
shabanu and pulan finds shabanu and pulan dinds nazir mahomes and dadi is kinf of felling angry , sad and mad as well. we can see this quote page 157 “ DADI’S EYES HARDEN AND suddently i see the wrestle croching in the circle of men , muscle bruch and blodust in the air” this quote tell us that dadi is kind of feeling sad and mad.
3. A dilemma is any situation requiring a choice between equal—often equally unpleasant—alternatives. Explain Shabanu’s dilemma when she and Phulan meet Nazir Mohammad and his hunters. Shabanu’s choosing to save her sister from rape leads to the story’s climax. On p.154, why is Shabanu angry at her sister?
pulan is fellinng afraid but shabanu dosent leaver her sister allone we can see this quote on page 154 that “ pulan puts her hand on hip and thrust it forward” this quote tell us that pullan is felling kind of afraid when she meet mahomes nazir but shabanu dosent leave pullan alone.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteWhat do Dadi and Shabanu encounter when they attempt to bury Grandfather? What appears to be lacking in the personalities of Sulaiman and the villagers in general?
ReplyDeleteDadi and Shabanu encounter to bury Grandfather , Sulaiman told them that they can not to bury her grandfather in this place, there are many years no people can bury in there. quotes from page133 “Nobody has been buried here in twenty years.”and page 135 “but the village is unfriendly,and Shahzada is the only helpful woul we’ve found here.”we can see that Sulaiman is Cruel because he does not let grandfather to bury in this land and the villagers not friendly because only Shahzada help them.
What do Shabanu and Phulan find while they are out hunting for sito? What do Dadi’s actions suggest about his character and beliefs?
Shabanu and Phulan found Nazir Mohammad and the bird he hunted. Dadi is angry but he also take care of his family, we can see in the quote on page 158, “Shabanu, you and Phulan help Auntie pack the most important things. Leave what isn’t important. Take the dowry, bedding, and food. But keep the fire going.” This quote tells us Dadi is take care for his family, he prepares everything done for his family, and then left himself.
A dilemma is any situation requiring a choice between equal—often equally unpleasant—alternatives. Explain Shabanu’s dilemma when she and Phulan meet Nazir Mohammad and his hunters. Shabanu’s choosing to save her sister from rape leads to the story’s climax. On p.154, why is Shabanu angry at her sister?
When they met Nazir Mohammad ,first Shabanu afraid that they will hurt Phulan but she can not go and left Phulan alone,but when Phulan see them ,she does not feel alarmed and still standing and looking .Quote on page 154 “Phulan put her hand on her hip and thrusts it forward....under her thin cotton tunic.”
Frances Mananghaya
ReplyDeleteWhat do Dadi and Shabanu encounter when they attempt to bury Grandfather? What appears to be lacking in the personalities of Sulaiman and the villagers in general?
-They are thirsty, the monsoon hasn’t come yet so they were looking for sito, a plant where they could get sweetwater. They don’t want to drink salty water if they have a choice. The Sulaiman and the villagers where they ran into aren’t nice at all.
- “After we have rested, Phulan and I walk out ahead of the others looking for sito, a fragrant grass with roots that run deep in the sand and are sweet with water.” p. 124
-This shows that Dadi and shabanu encounter drought, which is why they had a hard time looking for sito.
What do Shabanu and Phulan find while they are out hunting for sito? What do Dadi’s actions suggest about his character and beliefs?
-They ran into Nazir Mohammed, who is not a nice guy. “Nazir Mohammad, the landowner, has hunting parties. He offers each of his guest a girl, usually a tenant from his land, for the time they are with him. When the man is finished with her, he gives her cash and sends her back to her family.” This quotes shows about Nazir Mohammed.
A dilemma is any situation requiring a choice between equal—often equally unpleasant—alternatives. Explain Shabanu’s dilemma when she and Phulan meet Nazir Mohammad and his hunters. Shabanu’s choosing to save her sister from rape leads to the story’s climax. On p.154, why is Shabanu angry at her sister?
-Shabanu knows that when Nazir Mohammmed and his hunters see Phulan, they’ll gonna want her. So she tried to hide Phulan, but she failed. When they saw her, they chose her. Shabanu protected her sister so she hurt Nazir Mohammed, which made him very angry.
- “Nazir Mohammed tried to kidnap and rape my daughters.” p. 166
-This quote shows us that Nazir Mohammed tried to kidnap and rape Shabanu and Phulan.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteAnyara Rodriguez
ReplyDeleteWhat do Dadi and Shabanu encounter when they attempt to bury Grandfather? What appears to be lacking in the personalities of Sulaiman and the villagers in general?
Dadi and Shabanu had problems when they tried to bury grandfather at derawar. They tried to bury him where grandfather wanted but, the keeper of the tombs didn’t let dadi to bury grandfather because only nawabs’ wives can be buried there and no one had bury anyone for the last 20 years. Grandfather gave his life for the nawabs land but they did not accept him. On page 134 it explains, “The nawab doesn’t even have an army now, except for the bodyguard that protects his family from his enemies...” This shows that Dadi and shabanu tried to bury grandfathers dead body but they faced some consequences. Grandfather almost gave his life for the nawabs army but the tomb keeper did not let Dadi bury grandfather.
What do Shabanu and Phulan find while they are out hunting for sito? What do Dadi’s actions suggest about his character and beliefs?
Shabanu and Phulan find Nazir mohammad and his man hunting birds. They tried to take Phulan but shabanu and Phulan came back to the camp and told Dadi and he got mad as if he were going to kill Nazir and his men. On page 158 it says, “Dadi’s eyes are harden...No says mama,fear shaking in her voice. she stands and dadi comes out, the old country gun glinting gray and ugly in his hands “Abassi” she says, her eyes begging.” This shows Dadi got mad when he heard Nazir mohammad was coming for Phulan he took his gun and wanted to face them but Mama urge him to do not go. Dadi loves Shabanu and Phulan, he can’t let anything happen to them while he’s alive.
A dilemma is any situation requiring a choice between equal—often equally unpleasant—alternatives. Explain Shabanu’s dilemma when she and Phulan meet Nazir Mohammad and his hunters. Shabanu’s choosing to save her sister from rape leads to the story’s climax. On p.154, why is Shabanu angry at her sister?
When Shabanu met Nazir Mohammad and his hunters phulan wasn’t there but when she came back and saw nazir mohammad and his men, she looked defiantly. Shabanu has her own choices but also, she loves her sister, she can’t be without Phulan so she waited for Phulan and then they both ran away with xush dil and mithoo. Shabanu got angry at her sister because Phulan is acting like a boy if front of Nazir and his men. On page 155 it says, “we are both trapped. Both of us have jars of water on our heads. we can’t turn and ran away from this leering fat man. The of him sweating over phulan makes me ill.” This shows that shabanu had choices that either she could ran alone without taking phulan with her or she could stand there like a brave women and take her sister with her and ran away together. She didn’t want to give Phulan to Nazir mohammad’s hand because Phulan is getting married soon so Phulan does not need any other man.
What do Dadi and Shabanu encounter when they attempt to bury Grandfather? What appears to be lacking in the personalities of Sulaiman and the villagers in general? When Dadi and Shabanu encounter to bury Grandfather they have a problem and it’s that they can’t bury Grandfather in this place. On page 133 “ Nobody has been buried here in twenty years.” This quote show us that they can’t bury Grandfather in the Delaware.
ReplyDeleteWhat do Shabanu and Phulan find while they are out hunting for sito? What do Dadi’s actions suggest about his character and beliefs? When Shabanu and Phulan find Nazir Mohammad and the bird he hunted. Dadi was angry but he also take care his family, in the quote on page 158, “Shabanu, you and Phulan help Auntie pack the most important things. Leave what isn’t important. Take the dowry, bedding, and food. But keep the fire going.” This quote show us that the father take care for his family, he prepares everything done for his family, and then left himself.
A dilemma is any situation requiring a choice between equal—often equally unpleasant—alternatives. Explain Shabanu’s dilemma when she and Phulan meet Nazir Mohammad and his hunters. Shabanu’s choosing to save her sister from rape leads to the story’s climax. On p.154, why is Shabanu angry at her sister?That women should be protected and not used as tools for personal satisfaction , there are many people that just want to make money for fun while they’re actually damaging something else or someone in one way or the other. “Nazir Mohammed tried to kidnap and rape my daughters.” p. 166
This quote shows us that Nazir Mohammed tried to kidnap and rape Shabanu and Phulan.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDelete1. What do Dadi and Shabanu encounter when they attempt to bury Grandfather? What appears to be lacking in the personalities of Sulaiman and the villagers in general?
DeleteDadi and Shabanu had face that they trying to bury Grandfather and because they owe grandfather a try, they just want to give it back to grandfather, so Dadi want to bury grandfather by own but the keeper of tombs didn’t let him to bury grandfather and it’s because only nawabs wife is buried there
“We must try, dadi. grandfather wanted it. we owe him a try, at least.” Dadi doesn’t speak, but we head back around the tombs, behind the village, a scrappy place of mud huts with crude drawings of animals and men, stars and moons whitewashed on the walls, bare-bottomed children playing among the thorns, dogs running out to yap at the camel’s heels. on page 134
This quote shows us that dadi really want to bury grandfather but because some reasons, he can’t and they see the village is a scrappy place and people are playing around and dogs are running out to yap the camel.
2. What do Shabanu and Phulan find while they are out hunting for sito? What do Dadi’s actions suggest about his character and beliefs?
Shabanu and Phulan find Nazir Mohammad and Phulan’s laughter is hunting the birds so they going to take Phulan away then talk to Daid
They’re hunting quails by the canal. they’re coming for phulan when they’ve finished. they’re going to take her away!” on page 157
this quote shows us that they can’t make sounds to make birds scared but phulan’s laughter have been scare birds already so Dadi was very angry about her.
3. A dilemma is any situation requiring a choice between equal—often equally unpleasant—alternatives. Explain Shabanu’s dilemma when she and Phulan meet Nazir Mohammad and his hunters. Shabanu’s choosing to save her sister from rape leads to the story’s climax. On p.154, why is Shabanu angry at her sister?
Shabanu is angry at her sister because they get caught by Nazir Mohammad, but Phulan didn’t notice they are dangerous, so Shabanu feel angry about that.Shabanu and Phulan trapped by Nazir Mohammad and his hunters, she can not run by herself, but Phulan is not so agile if they run together. They may get caught by Nazir Mohammad again.
What do Dadi and Shabanu encounter when they attempt to bury Grandfather? What appears to be lacking in the personalities of Sulaiman and the villagers in general?
ReplyDeleteDadi and shabanu had problem when they tried to bury grandfather at derawar. They tried to to bury him where grandfather wanted them to but the keeper of the tombs didn’t let dadi to bury grandfather because only nawabs wife is buried there and no one had buried anyone for the last 20 years. Grandfather gave his life for the nawabs land but they denied him.
“The nawab doesn’t even have an army now, except for the bodyguard that protects his family from his enemies...” (pg 134)
This shows that Dadi and shabanu tried to bury grandfathers dead body but they faced some consequences. Grandfather almost gave his life for the nawabs army but the tomb keeper denied dadi to bury grandfather.
What do Shabanu and Phulan find while they are out hunting for sito? What do Dadi’s actions suggest about his character and beliefs?
Shabanu and phulan finds nazir mohammad and his man hunting birds.
“ Dadi’s eyes are harden...No says mama,fear shaking in her voice. she stands and dadi comes out, the old country gun glinting gray and ugly in his hands “Abassi” she says, her eyes begging” (pg 158).
This shows Dadi got mad when he heard nazir mohammad coming phulan he took his gun and tried to go and face them.
Dadi loves shabanu and phulan he can’t let anything happen to them when he’s alive.
A dilemma is any situation requiring a choice between equal—often equally unpleasant—alternatives. Explain Shabanu’s dilemma when she and Phulan meet Nazir Mohammad and his hunters. Shabanu’s choosing to save her sister from rape leads to the story’s climax. On p.154, why is Shabanu angry at her sister?
mohammad and his hunters phulan wasn’t there, but when she came back and saw nazir mohammad and his man she looked defiantly . Shabanu had choices but she loves her sister that she can’t run without phulan so she waited for phulan and then they both run away with xush dil and mithoo.
Shabanu got angry at her sister because phulan is acting with nazir mohammad and his mans as she’s not a girl but a boy.
Pamela Javier 5/3/2013
ReplyDeletems.Mann EES86QQR-56
1.What do Dadi and Shabanu encounter when they attempt to bury Grandfather? What appears to be lacking in the personalities of Sulaiman and the villagers in general?
when Dadi and Shabanu encounter to bury Grandfather , Sulaiman told them that they can not to bury her grandfather in this place, there are many years no people can bury in there. we can see that Sulaiman is Cruel because he does not let grandfather to bury in this land and the villagers not friendly because only Shahzada help them.quotes from page 133 “Nobody has been buried here in twenty years.”and page 135 “but the village is unfriendly,and Shahzada is the only helpful woul we’ve found here.”
2. What do Shabanu and Phulan find while they are out hunting for sito? What do Dadi’s actions suggest about his character and beliefs
They ran into Nazir Mohammed, who is not a nice guy. “Nazir Mohammad, the landowner, has hunting parties. He offers each of his guest a girl, usually a tenant from his land, for the time they are with him. When the man is finished with her, he gives her cash and sends her back to her family.” This quotes shows about Nazir Mohammed.
3.A dilemma is any situation requiring a choice between equal—often equally unpleasant—alternatives. Explain Shabanu’s dilemma when she and Phulan meet Nazir Mohammad and his hunters. Shabanu’s choosing to save her sister from rape leads to the story’s climax. On p.154, why is Shabanu angry at her sister?
When they met Nazir Mohammad ,first Shabanu afraid that they will hurt Phulan but she can not go and left Phulan alone,but when Phulan see them ,she does not feel alarmed and still standing and looking .Quote on page 154 “Phulan put her
What do Dadi and Shabanu encounter when they attempt to bury Grandfather? What appears to be lacking in the personalities of Sulaiman and the villagers in general?
ReplyDeleteAns: when dadi and Shabanu went to the encounter to make her grandfather wish they get trouble. at first they don’t give permission for bury her grandfather. first they speak with sulaiman but he say they can bury here. we see in page-133 “Nobody has been buried here in twenty years,”. It show us that first they didn't get permission.then they went to the commissioner . personalities of sulaiman was he was old and his voice was worn. he was keeper of tombs. the villagers general was VIP only vip person can meet with him and try to show his meager power.
What do Shabanu and Phulan find while they are out hunting for sito? What do Dadi’s actions suggest about his character and beliefs?
Phulan and Shabanu find Nazir Mohammed when they went to hunting for sito.We see in page-153 “ who is this?” asks a smooth, deep voice from the bottom of the canal bank.” When Dadi hair everything he get angry and get ready for make action for that those happened with her daughter. we see in page-157 “ Daddy's eyes harden, and suddenly I see the wrestler crouching in the circle of men, muscles bunched and bloodlust in the air.”
A dilemma is any situation requiring a choice between equally—often equally unpleasant—alternatives. Explain Shabanu’s dilemma when she and Phulan meet Nazir Mohammad and his hunters. Shabanu’s choosing to save her sister from rape leads to the story’s climax. On p.154, why is Shabanu angry at her sister?
This show us that when Shabanu and phulan meet with nazir mohammad and his hunter that time shabanu had choice between equally she can left her sister with hunter but she didn’t do it she wait for her sister without thinking about her life. she make a brave choice.we see in page 154 “when she sees the men she stops,but doesn't seem alarmed.she was angry with her sister because she can’t run faster.
1.What do Dadi and Shabanu encounter when they attempt to bury Grandfather? What appears to be lacking in the personalities of Sulaiman and the villagers in general?
ReplyDelete2.What do Shabanu and Phulan find while they are out hunting for sito? What do Dadi’s actions suggest about his character and beliefs?
3.A dilemma is any situation requiring a choice between equal—often equally unpleasant—alternatives. Explain Shabanu’s dilemma when she and Phulan meet Nazir Mohammad and his hunters. Shabanu’s choosing to save her sister from rape leads to the story’s climax. On p.154, why is Shabanu angry at her sister?
1. when badi and shabanu to bury grandfather, the man who named sulaiman told dadi and shabanu that this place don´t allow to bury dead bodies. as we can see that sulaiman and the villagers in general is very cruel and Ruthless because they don´t try to help them. they forced to stop dadi and shabanu to bury grandfather. we can find this on the quote in page 135 ‘ but the village is very unfriendly and shahzada is the only helpful would we’ve found here.’ people live there don’t want to help them and only one of most of them try to help them. they are ruthless.
2. shabanu and phulan find nazir mohammad and the bird. dadi is very angry and mad at them, because he is worried about them and want to take care of them. we can find this on quote in page 158, it says ‘ shabanu and phulan help auntie pack the most important things. leave what isn’t important. take the dowry, bedding, and food. but keep the fire going.’ from this quote, we can see dadi is a intelligent man he has Clarity of thought, he prepare everything as the fire happening. and he really care about his family.
3.when shabanu and phulan meet nazir mohammad and his hunters, she is very worried about phulan because phulan is beautiful and the man must will like phulan. and the reason of why shabanu angry is their mama warned them this man is very dangerous but phulan doesn’t aware that. and make herself in dangerous.
Inteshar Shakil
ReplyDelete1.What do Dadi and Shabanu encounter when they attempt to bury Grandfather? What appears to be lacking in the personalities of Sulaiman and the villagers in general?
2.What do Shabanu and Phulan find while they are out hunting for sito? What do Dadi’s actions suggest about his character and beliefs?
3.A dilemma is any situation requiring a choice between equal—often equally unpleasant—alternatives. Explain Shabanu’s dilemma when she and Phulan meet Nazir Mohammad and his hunters. Shabanu’s choosing to save her sister from rape leads to the story’s climax. On p.154, why is Shabanu angry at her sister?
1. Dadi and Shabanu both of them have to face problem when they tried to but grandfather in Derawar. They tried to bury him where grandfather wanted to burry him. When grandfather says that he want to die in Derawar then his voice started to get strong. One quote from page 119 is that “I want to die at Derawar Grandfather says, his voice stronger now.”The nawab will bury me in a martyr’s grave, with turquoise tiles and lapis carvings” This shows that he really want to die in Derawar
“The nawab doesn’t even have an army now, except for the bodyguard that protects his family from the enemies”. This shows that they want to buried grandfather in Derawar but they faced some problems.
2.Shabanu and Phulan both of them found Nazir Mohammad while they are are hunting for sito.“ Dadi’s eyes are harden...No says mama,fear shaking in her voice. she stands and dadi comes out, the old country gun glinting gray and ugly in his hands “Abassi” she
says, her eyes begging” from page 158. This means that dadi gets very angry with Nazir Mohammad. He took his gun out to kill him.
3. Nazir Mohammad and his hunters, captured Shabanu and Phulan.They are not letting them to go.Also, Shabanu get really scared of Nazir Mohammad because she thought that he’s gonna rape her sister.One quote from page 154 is that “Phulan put her hand on her hip and thrusts it forward....under her thin cotton tunic.”
This means that she really thought that he’s gonna reape her. So, she didn’t let her go alone.
Shiwei Lin
ReplyDelete1.What do Dadi and Shabanu encounter when they attempt to bury Grandfather? What appears to be lacking in the personalities of Sulaiman and the villagers in general?
When Dadi and Shabanu attempt to bury Grandfather, they encounter the prevention of villagers.We can see that in the quote on page 135, “It’ s our custom to feed villagers when there is a death. But the village is unfriendly, and Shahzada is the only helpful soul we’ve found here.” This quote shows us when Dadi and Shabanu try to bury Grandfather, the villagers are unfriendly to treat them.
2.What do Shabanu and Phulan find while they are out hunting for sito? What do Dadi’s actions suggest about his character and beliefs?
while they are out hunting for sito, they find nazir mohammad and his man hunting birds. Dadi is very calm, and he lets Shabanu and Phulan leave first. We can see this in the quote on page 158, “ Shabanu, you and Phulan help Auntie pack the most important things. Leave what isn’t important. Take the dowry, bedding, and food. But keep the fire going.” This quote shows us Dadi has protect Shabanu and Phulan. He is a good father.
3.A dilemma is any situation requiring a choice between equal—often equally unpleasant—alternatives. Explain Shabanu’s dilemma when she and Phulan meet Nazir Mohammad and his hunters. Shabanu’s choosing to save her sister from rape leads to the story’s climax. On p.154, why is Shabanu angry at her sister?
Shabanu angry at her sister, because Phulan doesn’t refuse these men. We can see this in the quote on page 154, “Phulan puts her hand on her hip and thrusts it forward, a defiant look on her face...oh, I could kill her.” This quote shows us Phulan doesn’t refuse the behavior of the men, and Shabanu sees that, so she feels angry for Phulan.
Li, Jian Hui
ReplyDeleteWhat do Dadi and Shabanu encounter when they attempt to bury Grandfather? What appears to be lacking in the personalities of Sulaiman and the villagers in general?
When Dadi and Shabanu attempt to bury Grandfather. Grandfather goes away. They feel scared. We can see this in the quote on page 111,”With my chadr over my face, I can open my eyes enough to see the haze of the lantern in Dadi’s hand, the light reflecting from the dust in a tight circle around him.” This shows that Shabanu and Dadi fear Grandfather will tell someone to help him. They go out to the courtyard and check it.
What do Shabanu and Phulan find while they are out hunting for sito? What do Dadi’s actions suggest about his character and beliefs?
While they are hunting for sito. They are finding a man who is ready to die. They help him. Shabanu and Phulan look at his strong face. We can this in the quote on page 126,”He was someone’s brother-by the grace of God he might have been my own.”This shows that Shabanu helps him and she would like him. Dadi would not allow her to look at the man. He is nearly angry. We can see this in the quote on page 127,”Dadi sits beside Grandfather, talking to him quietly.” This shows that Dadi may not agree him. He tells to his father to support his argument.
A dilemma is any situation requiring a choice between equal—often equally unpleasant—alternatives. Explain Shabanu’s dilemma when she and Phulan meet Nazir Mohammad and his hunters. Shabanu’s choosing to save her sister from rape leads to the story’s climax. On p.154, why is Shabanu angry at her sister?
Shabanu has to choose walk alone or talking to Phulan. She can be like a brave woman and carry her to run away the dune. On page 155,”we are trapped. both of us have jars of water on your heads. we can’t turn and run away from this leering fat man “she didn’t wants to give phulan on nazir mohammad’s hand because phulan is getting married soon and she wiil have a good future.
David Madrid EES6QQR
ReplyDeleteMs.Mann 05/03/13
Blog 10 Analyzing Shabanu
What do Dadi and Shabanu encounter when they attempt to bury Grandfather? What appears to be lacking in the personalities of Sulaiman and the villagers in general?
What do Shabanu and Phulan find while they are out hunting for sito? What do Dadi’s actions suggest about his character and beliefs?
A dilemma is any situation requiring a choice between equal—often equally unpleasant—alternatives. Explain Shabanu’s dilemma when she and Phulan meet Nazir Mohammad and his hunters. Shabanu’s choosing to save her sister from rape leads to the story’s climax. On p.154, why is Shabanu angry at her sister?
1. Shabanu and her father got a problem when they went to bury the grandfather. Also, grandfather gave the life for the nawabs, but the nawabs denied his bury. “ The nawab doesn’t even have an army now, expect for the bodyguard that protects his family from his enemies...”pg 134
This quote show us the problem the Shabanu and his father were facing to bury the grandfather.
2. Shabanu and Phulan found a Nazir Mohammad and another man hunting birds. Nazir and his man tried to take a Phulan but they come back to the camp they went to dadi and told him what nazir and the other man did, and he went like he will kill nazir. “Hamir will need to know. The landlord knows who we are.”pg 154. This quote show us the Dadi was ungry and he will defend his daughter.
3. The women are a beautiful give the god give us and it’s not fear the some people look the women just for have a fun or do with her whatever they want. We’ll pay you handsomely land, jewelry, money, anything you like.”pg 154.
This quote show us how the men treat the women like a prostitute or try to has a fun for while with them.
What do Dadi and Shabanu encounter when they attempt to bury Grandfather? What appears to be lacking in the personalities of Sulaiman and the villagers in general?
ReplyDeleteDadi and shabanu had problem when they tried to bury grandfather at derawar. They tried to to bury him where grandfather wanted them to but the keeper of the tombs didn’t allow Dadii to bury grandfather because only nawabs wife was buried. Grandfather gave his life to the nawabs but in the end they denied him.”The nawab doesn’t even have an army now, except for the bodyguard that protects his family from his enemies...” (pg 134) this quote shows that Dadi and Shabanu try to bury grandfather there but the tomb’s guard did’nt allow it, and grandfather give his life to nawabs but didn’t get what he desevre.
2 What do Shabanu and Phulan find while they are out hunting for sito? What do Dadi’s actions suggest about his character and beliefs?
Shabanu and phulan finds nazir mohammad and his man hunting birds. They tried to take phulan but shabanu and phulan came back to the camp and told dadi and dadi got mad as if he’s going to kill nazir and his mens. “ Dadi’s eyes are harden...No says mama,fear shaking in her voice. she stands and dadi comes out, the old country gun glinting gray and ugly in his hands “Abassi” she says, her eyes begging” (pg 158) this quote shows that Dadi was angry and take out the gun,Dadi loves shabanu and phulan he can’t let anything happen to them when he’s alive.
3 A dilemma is any situation requiring a choice between equal—often equally unpleasant—alternatives. Explain Shabanu’s dilemma when she and Phulan meet Nazir Mohammad and his hunters. Shabanu’s choosing to save her sister from rape leads to the story’s climax. On p.154, why is Shabanu angry at her sister?
When they met Nazir Mohammad first, Shabanu was afraid that they will hurt Phulan but she can not go and left Phulan alone, when Phulan saw them ,she does not feel alarmed and still standing and looking .“we are both trapped. Both of us have jars of water on our heads. we can’t turn and ran away from this leering fat man. The of him sweating over phulan makes me ill” (page 155 ) this quote means Shabanu is a brave women, she had choice that run sway but she didn’t do it ,she stay with phulan.
ReplyDelete1. Dadi and Shabanu has encountered a lot of difficulties with her father.On page 135 it says” Dadi and I are interested,but we explain that we must hurry to find a burial place for grandfather. He seems truly sorry not to be able to help. He directs us to the village of the tomb maker. We ….......It’s our custom to feed villagers when there is a death. But the village is unfriendly.”The meaning for this quote is that Dadi and Shabanu is having a hard time and she also talks about the customs.”
2. Phulan and Shabanu found that is was really hard to find sito. On page 124 it says”We’d been three days with no water, and Uncle found sito far from the track in the area of the largest dunes.”
3. Shabanu had a dilemma when she and Phulan met Nazir Mohammad and his hunters.On page 154 it says “Phulan puts her hand on her hip and thrusts it forward ,a defiant look on her face. Her breasts are high and frim under her thin cotton tunic
Yeison Estrella
ReplyDeleteWhat do Dadi and Shabanu encounter when they attempt to bury Grandfather? What appears to be lacking in the personalities of Sulaiman and the villagers in general?
What do Shabanu and Phulan find while they are out hunting for sito? What do Dadi’s actions suggest about his character and beliefs?
A dilemma is any situation requiring a choice between equal—often equally unpleasant—alternatives. Explain Shabanu’s dilemma when she and Phulan meet Nazir Mohammad and his hunters. Shabanu’s choosing to save her sister from rape leads to the story’s climax. On p.154, why is Shabanu angry at her sister?
1. What do Dadi and Shabanu encounter when they attempt to bury Grandfather? What appears to be lacking in the personalities of Sulaiman and the villagers in general?Dadi and shabanu had problem when they tried to bury grandfather at derawar. They tried to bury him where grandfather wanted them to bury him but the keeper of the tombs didn’t let dadi to bury grandfather because only nawabs wife is buried there and no one had buried anyone for the last 20 years. Grandfather gave his life for the nawabs land but they denied him.“The nawab doesn’t even have an army now, except for the bodyguard that protects his family from his enemies...” (pg 134)As we can see that Dadi and shabanu tried to bury grandfathers dead body in the place that he have to be but they face some problems for the can put they grandfather in the bury that he wanted before he die. Grandfather almost gave his life for the nawabs army.
2.What do Shabanu and Phulan find while they are out hunting for sito? What do Dadi’s actions suggest about his character and beliefs?
Shabanu and Phulan find Nazir Mohammad and the bird he hunted. Dadi is angry but he also take care with his family, we can see in the quote on page 158, “Shabanu, you and Phulan help Auntie pack the most important things. Leave what isn’t important. Take the dowry, bedding, and food. But keep the fire going.” As we can see this quote tells us Dadi take care his family, he prepares everything done for his family
.
3) A dilemma is any situation requiring a choice between equal—often equally unpleasant—alternatives. Explain Shabanu’s dilemma when she and Phulan meet Nazir Mohammad and his hunters. Shabanu’s choosing to save her sister from rape leads to the story’s climax. On p.154, why is Shabanu angry at her sister?When Shabanu and met nazir mohammad and his hunters phulan wasn’t there butwhen she came back and saw nazir mohammad and his man she looked defiantly . Shabanu had choices but she loves her sister that she can’t run without phulan so she waited for phulan and then they both run away with xush dil and mithoo. Shabanu got angry at her sister because phulan is acting with nazir mohammad and his mans as she’s not a girl but a boy. As we can see in the quote“we are both trapped. Both of us have jars of water on our heads. we can’t turn and ran away from this leering fat man. The of him sweating over phulan makes me ill” (page 155)
As we can see this shows that shabanu had choices that either she could ran alone without taking phulan with her or she could stand there like a brave women and take her sister with her and ran away together.
liu,shuping
ReplyDelete1) What do Dadi and Shabanu encounter when they attempt to bury Grandfather? What appears to be lacking in the personalities of Sulaiman and the villagers in general?
Dadi and Shabanu attempt to bury Grandfather that they must be hurry.They tried to find out places to bury Grandfather but they met some problem.We can see this quote on page 135, “It’s our custom to feed village when there is a death.But the villager is unfriendly,and Shahzada is the only helpful soul we’ve found here.”This quote shows us the villager didn’t want they come here to bury Grangfather but just Shahzada to helped them to find.
2) What do Shabanu and Phulan find while they are out hunting for sito? What do Dadi’s actions suggest about his character and beliefs?
Shabanu and Phulan found quail by the canal and hunt that.Also, thay wanted to take her far away but Dadi was angry.We can see this quote on page 157, “‘they say they’ll pay.they want her.they saw Mithoo coming here,and the fire was burning.’”This quote shows us Dadi didn’t wants his daughters been in dangerous even thought he knew they have many problem.
3) A dilemma is any situation requiring a choice between equal—often equally unpleasant—alternatives. Explain Shabanu’s dilemma when she and Phulan meet Nazir Mohammad and his hunters. Shabanu’s choosing to save her sister from rape leads to the story’s climax. On p.154, why is Shabanu angry at her sister?
Shabanu anger at her sister because her sister is pretty and she didn’t refuse other man.
1 What do Dadi and Shabanu encounter when they attempt to bury Grandfather? What appears to be lacking in the personalities of Sulaiman and the villagers in general?
ReplyDeleteDadi and shabanu have a problem with bury Grandfather. they feel tried with to gandfather’s request. garandfather want to the bury to nawabs land ,but the keeper of the tombs didn’t let dadi to bury grandfather because only nawabs wife is buried there. Grandfather gave his life for the nawabs land but they denied him. page 135 “but the village is unfriendly,and Shahzada is the only helpful woul we’ve found here.”
2What do Shabanu and Phulan find while they are out hunting for sito? What do Dadi’s actions suggest about his character and beliefs?
Shabanu and Phulan find Nazir Mohammad and his laughters are hunting the birds,and they saw Phulan ,also wants to take her away,later they go back and tell to their dadi. Quote on page 157 “‘they say they’ll pay.they want her.they saw Mithoo coming here,and the fire was burning.’”
when dadi heard that ,he take out the gun and angry ,he knows that they have problems coming soon.he does not wants his daughters been in dangerous. Quote on page 157 “she stands and dadi comes out ,the old country hun glinting gray and ugly in his hands.”
3 A dilemma is any situation requiring a choice between equal—often equally unpleasant—alternatives. Explain Shabanu’s dilemma when she and Phulan meet Nazir Mohammad and his hunters. Shabanu’s choosing to save her sister from rape leads to the story’s climax. On p.154, why is Shabanu angry at her sister?
Shabanu and Phulan trapped by Nazir Mohammad and his hunters,Shabanu can leave by herself , she want to leave with Phulan . but She didn’t want to give phulan on nazir mohammad’s hand because phulan is getting married soon and she will have a good future.” we are both trapped. Both of us have jars of water on our heads. we can’t turn and ran away from this leering fat man. The of him sweating over phulan makes me ill” (page 155)
What do Dadi and Shabanu encounter when they attempt to bury Grandfather? What appears to be lacking in the personalities of Sulaiman and the villagers in general?
ReplyDeleteWhat do Shabanu and Phulan find while they are out hunting for sito? What do Dadi’s actions suggest about his character and beliefs?
A dilemma is any situation requiring a choice between equal—often equally unpleasant—alternatives. Explain Shabanu’s dilemma when she and Phulan meet Nazir Mohammad and his hunters. Shabanu’s choosing to save her sister from rape leads to the story’s climax. On p.154, why is Shabanu angry at her sister?
1. Dadi and Shabanu has encountered a lot of difficulties with her father.On page 135 it says” Dadi and I are interested,but we explain that we must hurry to find a burial place for grandfather. He seems truly sorry not to be able to help. He directs us to the village of the tomb maker. We ….......It’s our custom to feed villagers when there is a death. But the village is unfriendly.”The meaning for this quote is that Dadi and Shabanu is having a hard time and she also talks about the customs.”
2. Phulan and Shabanu found that is was really hard to find sito. On page 124 it says”We’d been three days with no water, and Uncle found sito far from the track in the area of the largest dunes.”
3. Shabanu had a dilemma when she and Phulan met Nazir Mohammad and his hunters.On page 154 it says “Phulan puts her hand on her hip and thrusts it forward ,a defiant look on her face. Her breasts are high and firm under her thin cotton tunic.”
What do Dadi and Shabanu encounter when they attempt to bury Grandfather? What appears to be lacking in the personalities of Sulaiman and the villagers in general?
ReplyDeleteWhen Dadi and Shabanu attempt to bury Grandfather, Sulaiman doesn’t let them bury their Grandfather, because in this place was twenty years no one can bury,only Shahzada want to help them. The quote was in page 135 “Nobody has been buried here in twenty years.” This shows us the village was not friendly to them.
2. What do Shabanu and Phulan find while they are out hunting for sito? What do Dadi’s actions suggest about his character and beliefs?
Shabanu and Phulan find Nazir Mohammad and hunting man. When Dadi knows , he feels angry, he doesn’t want them be dangerous. The quote in page 158“Shabanu, you and Phulan help Auntie pack the most important things. Take the dowry, bedding, and food. But keep the fire going. ” This shows us Dadi was take care about his family, and protect them.
3.A dilemma is any situation requiring a choice between equal—often equally unpleasant—alternatives. Explain Shabanu’s dilemma when she and Phulan meet Nazir Mohammad and his hunters. Shabanu’s choosing to save her sister from rape leads to the story’s climax. On p.154, why is Shabanu angry at her sister?
Shabanu was afraid for Nazir Mohammad for the first seeing, she wants to run away, but she can’t do it, because her sister was still beside with her, she can’t run for herself.
What do Dadi and Shabanu encounter when they attempt to bury Grandfather? What appears to be lacking in the personalities of Sulaiman and the villagers in general?
ReplyDeleteShabanu and her father have problem with to bury grandfather, they are encounter the grandfather to bury in here. Sulaiman told to them cannot to bury here. “nobody has been buried here in twenty years,” he says finally.(133)There are lacking in the personalities and the villagers in general. I think Sulaiman is friendly with them.
What do Shabanu and Phulan find while they are out hunting for sito? What do Dadi’s actions suggest about his character and beliefs?
Shabanu and Phulan found Nazir Mohammad luagher are hunting the bird. The man saw the Phulan want to take her go to, Phulan felt fear of them. “They say they’ll pay. They want her. They saw Mithoo coming here, and the fire was burning.” The words tumble out.(157) Dadi is angry of them are bully his daughter that Dadi take gun out.
A dilemma is any situation requiring a choice between equal—often equally unpleasant—alternatives. Explain Shabanu’s dilemma when she and Phulan meet Nazir Mohammad and his hunters. Shabanu’s choosing to save her sister from rape leads to the story’s climax. On p.154, why is Shabanu angry at her sister?
Shabanu was angry about her sister talking about deal with the man， the Mama told to them go away of those man， but she didn't listen to the Mama. So， Shabanu felt angry about that.“We'll pay you handsomely-land,jewelry,money,anything you like."(154)This quote shows the man want Phulan with them to go,then, they'll pay for her anything she want.
1.What do Dadi and Shabanu encounter when they attempt to bury Grandfather? What appears to be lacking in the personalities of Sulaiman and the villagers in general?
ReplyDelete-The keeper of the tombs won’t let them bury the Grandfather.
-This show on page 133,“Nobody has been allowed on the property for five years, since the dispute went to court.”
-They are unfriendly and careless to others.
2.What do Shabanu and Phulan find while they are out hunting for sito? What do Dadi’s actions suggest about his character and beliefs?
-They found nazir mohammad and his man hunting birds.
-On page 158, “ Shabanu, you and Phulan help Auntie pack the most important things. Leave what isn’t important. Take the dowry, bedding, and food. But keep the fire going.”
-This quote shows us that Dadi is trying to protect his family from dangerous that will happen.
3.A dilemma is any situation requiring a choice between equal—often equally unpleasant—alternatives. Explain Shabanu’s dilemma when she and Phulan meet Nazir Mohammad and his hunters. Shabanu’s choosing to save her sister from rape leads to the story’s climax. On p.154, why is Shabanu angry at her sister?
-Shabanu angry at her sister, because Phulan doesn’t refuse these men. -On page 154, “Phulan puts her hand on her hip and thrusts it forward, a defiant look on her face...oh, I could kill her.”
-This quote shows us Phulan doesn’t refuse the behavior of the men, and Shabanu saw that, so she feels angry at Phulan.